Plug Y Play S
9,0/10 4,9 (272)
Plug Y Play S stands out for its design and ease of use, ideal for beginners and advanced users.
10,95 âŹSee product
What are the best anal plugs of 2026?
We've rated 16 anal plugs âmetal, silicone, glass, inflatable, and kitsâ with verified purchase reviews, actual purchases from the last 24 months, their price and technical data. Here are the top 10 and who each one is for.
- 16 rated modelsof 295 in stock
- 439 reviewsverified purchase
- Real purchaseslast 24 months
- 16/10/2026latest review
Text of Anel Martinez · Sexologist
Ranking calculated with data from the shop and reviewed by VivelaVita product team
The best anal plugs of 2026
One for every need. If youâre in a rush, start here.
Mini Metal Butt Plug S
8,9/10 4,9 (11)
Small, sleek and economical metal anal plug, ideal for beginners and travel.
9,50 âŹSee product
Anal Trainer Kit
6,9/10 4,6 (32)
Progressive kit for getting started with anal plugs, flexible and easy to clean.
28,76 âŹSee product
Mini Metal Butt Plug M
8,7/10 5,0 (7)
Elegant metal plug, waterproof and easy to clean, ideal for those seeking quality and design.
11,95 âŹSee product
Inflatable Butt Plug L
7,9/10 4,7 (7)
Inflatable silicone plug with suction cup, flexible and non-phallic shape, ideal for advanced users.
25,20 âŹSee product
Comparison of the top 10 anal plugs
In 'Material', you see what each one is made of, and in 'Level', who each is for.
| # | Product | Best for | Rating | Material | Level | Feel | Jewel | Vibrates | Price | Reviews | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Plug Y Play SSecret Play | Best overall | 9,0/10 | Metal | Beginner | Rigid | With jewel | No | 10,95 ⏠| 4,9 (272) | View |
| 2 |  Mini Metal Butt Plug SAlive | Best value for money | 8,9/10 | Metal | Beginner | Rigid | With jewel | No | 9,50 ⏠| 4,9 (11) | View |
| 3 |  Mini Metal Butt Plug MAlive | Best metal plug | 8,7/10 | Metal | Intermediate | Rigid | With jewel | No | 11,95 ⏠| 5,0 (7) | View |
| 4 |  Plug & PlaySecret Play | â | 8,0/10 | Metal | Intermediate | Rigid | With jewel | No | 20,50 ⏠| 5,0 (22) | View |
| 5 |  Inflatable Butt Plug LSeven Creations | Best silicone plug | 7,9/10 | Silicone | Advanced | Flexible | No | No | 25,20 ⏠| 4,7 (7) | View |
| 6 |  Plug Silexd ConicoSilexd | â | 7,8/10 | Silicone | Advanced | Flexible | No | No | 14,95 ⏠| 4,4 (18) | View |
| 7 |  Sono NÂș 50Shots | â | 7,3/10 | â | Advanced | â | No | No | 15,85 ⏠| 4,6 (5) | View |
| 8 |  Anal Trainer KitCalexotics | Best for beginners | 6,9/10 | PVC | Beginner | Flexible | No | No | 28,76 ⏠| 4,6 (32) | View |
| 9 |  Plug Play LargoSecret Play | â | 6,9/10 | Metal | Beginner | â | With jewel | No | 20,95 ⏠| 5,0 (6) | View |
| 10 |  Icicles NÂș47Pipedream | â | 6,9/10 | Glass | Intermediate | â | No | No | 16,95 ⏠| 4,7 (7) | View |
15%
FOR EXTRA DISCOUNT
Use the code: BLOGVIVE and get an extra discount at Vivelavita to buy anal plugs.
BLOGVIVE
How we choose the best
No random scores. Each plug is rated with the same data and the same formula, and the formula is published. Whether it's metal or silicone doesn't give it an edge on its own: it indicates who it's for, and that's why we point it out separately.
- Buyer reviews40 %Verified purchase reviews on VivelaVita: one per review, no reviews from other shops or repeated translations
- Actual purchases25 %Paid orders from the last 24 months, in net units after returns
- Price10 %RRP including VAT compared to the median of the models analysed
- Material10 %Specification sheet: silicone, metal or glass, phthalate-free, non-porous, hypoallergenic; compared to PVC and ABS plastic
- Shape and feel8 %Specification sheet: non-phallic shape, flexible and smooth texture
- Use and cleaning7 %Technical sheet: waterproof, easy to clean and travel-friendly
16 of 295 models in stock had at least 5 verified purchase reviews, which is the minimum to rate them. The rest aren't worse: there's no data to say so.
If we change the weights, the number 1 stays in 13 of 13 combinations.
See full methodologyAnalysis of each plug
VivelaVita's rating9,0/10
Why we chose it
It's number 1 in overall score, shape and feel, and usage and cleaning, with high rating and purchase rate. Its conical design and metallic material enhance the experience and cleaning.
The best bits
- Metallic material allows temperature play and is easy to clean
- Ideal for beginners and advanced users
Things to consider
- Price slightly above the median but justified by quality and features
- Small size that may not be suitable for everyone
- Can be uncomfortable in some positions or after prolonged use
Ideal for
Beginners in anal stimulationUsers looking for ease of cleaningCouples wanting to experiment with anal play
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a more budget-friendly metal plug, I'd choose Mini Metal Butt Plug S by Alive. See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
4,9 (272 verified)
Users positively rate its size for beginners, ease of cleaning, and metallic material that allows for temperature play. Some mention the size might be small and in certain positions could be uncomfortable.
+ Size and comfort + Material and cleaning â Size and fit
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsMini Metal Butt Plug S
Alive · Elegant, refreshing and comfortable metal anal plug with jewel
Best value for moneyVivelaVita's rating8,9/10
Why we chose it
Stands out for its price and shape, being the cheapest and best feel of the 10 models. Its overall score is high, with good buyer ratings and purchase rate.
The best bits
- Very competitive price
- Shape and feel without phallic form and smooth texture
- High buyer rating
Things to consider
- Metal material with a cool feel
- Use and cleaning with lower score
- Doesn't have vibration, might be less stimulating for some
Ideal for
Beginners in anal plugsThose looking for an affordable metal plug
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a plug with vibration and similar features, I'd choose Plug Y Play S. See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
4,9 (11 verified)
Users positively rate the beginner-friendly size, quality of the metal, and cool sensation. They also highlight the smoothness on entry and elegant design.
+ Size and comfort + Quality and design
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsMini Metal Butt Plug M
Alive · Elegant metal anal plug with diamond, IPX8, lightweight
Best metal plugVivelaVita's rating8,7/10
Why we chose it
Stands out as the no. 1 in use and cleaning, with good rating and competitive price. Its metal design with jewel adds elegance and functionality.
The best bits
- Well-rated by buyers
- Competitive price
- Metal material with jewel
Things to consider
- Non-phallic design
Ideal for
TravellingEnhance orgasmsEase anal sex
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you're looking for a plug with better overall rating, I'd choose Plug Y Play S See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
5,0 (7 verified)
Users appreciate the quality of the material, the elegant design with jewel and ease of use, highlighting its size and ease to store.
+ Quality and design + Couple use
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsPlug & Play
Secret Play · Medium anal plug, easy to use and clean, waterproof
VivelaVita's rating8,0/10
Why we chose it
This anal plug is #1 in customer ratings, shape and feel, and ease of use and cleaning. Its non-phallic form and smooth texture make it comfortable and easy to clean.
The best bits
- #1 in customer ratings
- #1 in shape and feel
- #1 in use and cleaning
Things to consider
- Price slightly above the median
- Metallic material that might not appeal to everyone
Ideal for
Introduction to anal stimulationCouple useTravel and easy cleaning
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a cheaper plug with similar features, I would choose Plug Y Play S. See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
5,0 (22 verified)
Users rate its comfort, ease of use and cleaning, as well as its stylish design and suitable size for beginners.
+ Comfort and ease of use + Design and material + Cleaning and transport
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsInflatable Butt Plug L
Seven Creations · Silicone device with suction cup and size adjustment, Seven Creations
Best silicone plugVivelaVita's rating7,9/10
Why we chose it
Stands out for its shape and feel, being the no. 1 in this criterion, and its ease of use and cleaning. Although its price is slightly higher, it offers an adjustable and safe experience.
The best bits
- Non-phallic and flexible shape, which improves comfort and adaptation.
- Easy to use and clean, waterproof.
- Silicone and ABS plastic material, safe for anal use.
Things to consider
- Price slightly above the market median.
- Some users notice that the inflation isn't even.
Ideal for
Users experienced in anal stimulationCouples looking to explore new sensationsThose who are after an adjustable and safe plug
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a plug with better value for money, I would choose Mini Metal Butt Plug S. See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
4,7 (7 verified)
Users value the quality of the material and the experience of use, although some mention that inflation can be uneven and the balloon moves relative to the inner tube.
+ Quality and material + User experience â Inflation
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsPlug Silexd Conico
Silexd · Premium silicone anal plug, hypoallergenic and flexible
VivelaVita's rating7,8/10
Why we chose it
Stands out for its hypoallergenic and phthalate-free silicone material, being the best in this regard. Its flexibility and large size make it suitable for experienced users, although its shape and feel are less appreciated.
The best bits
- Hypoallergenic and phthalate-free silicone material
- Flexible and ergonomic for greater comfort
Things to consider
- Less valued shape and feel, ranked 10 out of 10
- Large size, requires experience to use
- Small base can make removal tricky
Ideal for
Experienced usersThose seeking hypoallergenic materialPeople who prefer flexible plugs
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you're looking for a smaller and easier to handle plug, I would choose the Plug Y Play S from Secret Play. See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
4,4 (18 verified)
Users appreciate the quality of the material and flexibility but warn that the size is large, and the small base can make removal tricky.
+ Material + Flexibility and comfort â Size â Base and removal
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsSono NÂș 50
Shots · Anal dilator with rings of various sizes
VivelaVita's rating7,3/10
The best bits
- Use and cleaning: su ficha indica resistente al agua, fĂĄcil limpieza, viajar
- Highly rated by buyers: 4.6/5 in 5 verified reviews
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
Anal Trainer Kit
Calexotics · Set of 3 progressive anal plugs in soft, flexible vinyl
Best for beginnersVivelaVita's rating6,9/10
Why we chose it
This kit stands out for its flexibility and ease of cleaning, ideal for beginners. Although its price is high and the material is PVC, its progressive design makes adaptation easier.
The best bits
- Flexible and with a smooth texture for added comfort
- Easy to clean and waterproof
- Ideal for beginners in anal sex
- Progressive kit with three sizes for gradual adaptation
Things to consider
- High price compared to other plugs
- PVC material, less valued than other materials
- Some users notice a strong smell at first
Ideal for
Those starting out in anal sexUsers looking for a progressive kitPeople who value ease of cleaning
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a plug with better value for money, I would choose Mini Metal Butt Plug S. See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
4,6 (32 verified)
Users appreciate the comfort and progression of the kit for starting out, although some mention a strong smell and difficulty with the larger plug.
+ Comfort and progression + Material and feel â Smell â Difficulty with the large plug
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsPlug Play Largo
Secret Play · Tapered anal plug for stimulation; suitable for everyone
VivelaVita's rating6,9/10
Why we chose it
It ranks 9th in the overall score and stands out in buyer ratings and metallic material. Its large size and non-phallic design make it suitable for those seeking a different experience.
The best bits
- High buyer rating with an average of 5.0/5 in 6 reviews
- Metallic aluminium material that makes cleaning easy
- Non-phallic design for a different experience
- Ideal for beginners and compatible with silicone and water-based lubricants
Things to consider
- Price slightly above the market median
- No information about use and cleaning in the product description
Ideal for
Beginners in anal stimulationThose looking for a large, metallic plugUsers who prefer non-phallic design
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you're looking for a more affordable plug with better ratings, I would choose Plug Y Play S See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
5,0 (6 verified)
Users appreciate its size, ease of cleaning, and comfort. They highlight its use with lubricants and the possibility of heating or cooling it for different sensations.
+ Size and comfort + Material and cleaning
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsIcicles NÂș47
Pipedream · Glass anal plug, hypoallergenic, temperature changing
VivelaVita's rating6,9/10
Why we chose it
It ranks 10th in the general comparison, but it's number 1 in form and touch and use and cleanliness. Its non-phallic design and easy cleaning make it unique.
The best bits
- Crystal material, non-porous
- Glass anal plug, hypoallergenic, temperature changing
Things to consider
- Price slightly high compared to the median
- Low purchase rate compared to other models
Ideal for
Those looking for a plug that's easy to cleanUsers who prefer non-porous materialsPeople who appreciate a non-phallic design
Would choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a plug with a better overall score, I would choose Plug Y Play S. See analysis
See score by criteria and reviews
Score by criteria
What customers say
4,7 (7 verified)
Users appreciate its design and the pleasure it provides, highlighting its quality and ease of use.
+ pleasure + quality and design
Summary made with AI from verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsWhich one to choose? It depends on what you're looking for
Tap on what you're looking for, and we'll tell you which one.
It's my first plug
Anal Trainer Kit6,9/10 · 28,76 âŹSee recommendationI want it in metal
Mini Metal Butt Plug M8,7/10 · 11,95 âŹSee recommendationI want it in silicone, soft
Inflatable Butt Plug L7,9/10 · 25,20 âŹSee recommendationI want to spend less
Mini Metal Butt Plug S8,9/10 · 9,50 âŹSee recommendationJust give me the best one
Plug Y Play S9,0/10 · 10,95 âŹSee recommendation
Anal Trainer Kit6,9/10 · 28,76 âŹSee recommendationI want it in metalMini Metal Butt Plug M8,7/10 · 11,95 âŹSee recommendationI want it in silicone, softInflatable Butt Plug L7,9/10 · 25,20 âŹSee recommendationI want to spend lessMini Metal Butt Plug S8,9/10 · 9,50 âŹSee recommendationJust give me the best onePlug Y Play S9,0/10 · 10,95 âŹSee recommendationWhat to look for before buying
What to consider when evaluating the opinion of other buyers?
The ratings from other buyers can be a great ally in your purchasing decision. It is essential that you pay attention to the reviews published by users with verified orders in our store. These opinions reflect authentic experiences, allowing you to have a clear idea of what the product is like in practice. Don't just be swayed by the positive comments; also pay attention to constructive criticism.
How much should you invest in an anal plug?
Price is an important consideration and can vary depending on the materials and features of the anal plug. Compare the price of the plug you are interested in with the median of the models analyzed in the table. Remember that a higher price does not always mean better quality, but neither should you skimp too much on this type of product, as cheaper materials may affect the experience.
The importance of material: silicone, metal, or glass
When looking for an anal plug, the material is key. Silicone, metal, or glass models are the most recommended because they are hypoallergenic and non-porous, making them easy to clean and safe for intimate use. Avoid materials like PVC or ABS plastic, which may not offer the same guarantees of quality and safety.
Why do shape and texture matter?
The shape and texture of the anal plug are essential aspects for comfortable use. Look for models without a phallic shape, with flexible design and smooth texture for delicate and pleasurable insertion. Flexibility and a smooth finish can significantly improve your experience, ensuring the plug fits comfortably to your anatomy.
Make your life easier with a plug that is easy to clean and transport
Opt for an anal plug that is water-resistant, as this greatly facilitates cleaning. A plug that is easy to carry on trips will provide discretion and comfort, ensuring you can enjoy your intimate moments anywhere. Practicality in these aspects will enhance your overall experience with the product.
When is the ideal time to try different features such as jewels or vibrations?
Exploring new sensations can take your experience to another level. If you are used to basic anal plugs, it might be time to try models with jewels or vibration features. These characteristics not only add an aesthetic touch but also offer additional stimuli that can be very pleasurable. Evaluate if you're ready to incorporate these elements into your erotic games.
Frequently asked questions
What's the best butt plug?
According to this review, the Plug Y Play S, with 9,0/10. But it depends on what you're looking for: if it's your first, the Anal Trainer Kit; metal, the Mini Metal Butt Plug M; silicone, the Inflatable Butt Plug L; and if you're looking at price, the Mini Metal Butt Plug S.
Better metal or silicone plug?
The metal one is rigid, heavier and more noticeable when worn; it can be warmed or cooled with water. The silicone one is soft and flexible. Both are easy to clean. The highest-rated metal one is the Mini Metal Butt Plug M and for silicone, it's the Inflatable Butt Plug L.
Why isn't the best-seller always first?
Because purchases make up a quarter of the score. The rest comes from buyer reviews, price, and what the listing says about material, shape, and cleaning. A less sold, better-rated, and cheaper plug can come out on top.
Is a multi-size kit worth it?
If you're unsure which size suits you, yes: it comes with various sizes to try out. In this comparison, a kit counts as one product, with its kit price.
Are there vibrating plugs or ones with jewels?
Yes. In the 'Vibrate' and 'Jewelled' columns of the table, you can see which ones have these features. Vibrating or having a jewel doesn't increase the score: they're rated with the same criteria as the others.
Which has the best value for money?
The Mini Metal Butt Plug S: it's the highest-rated among those costing less than average, and it costs 9,50 âŹ.
How many plugs have you analysed?
We started with 295 butt plugs in stock. We rated the 16 that have enough verified purchase reviews, and here are the best 10.
About this comparison
- Last review
- 16/10/2026 · version 31 of the ranking
- Text
- Anel Martinez, sexologist
- Ranking
- Calculated with the mejores-v1 algorithm and reviewed by the VivelaVita product team
- Data analysed
- 295 models in stock, 16 rated, 439 verified purchase reviews and orders paid for in 24 months
The order and scores are those of the version published on 16/10/2026. Price, stock, and the number of reviews update on their own and may have changed: check the product details before buying.
See all anal plugsFull methodology
Which products are included
All items from the category and its subcategories that are currently active, in stock and priced (295 models). Accessories and spare parts, discontinued items and those with less than 5 verified purchase reviews are excluded for scoring: 279 models that arenât worse, but simply donât have enough data.
What data is used
Only reviews with a real order behind them, counted once even if they are translated into several languages; never reviews copied from other stores. Sales from paid orders over the last 24 months, excluding returns. The technical sheet of each model. The price including VAT. And incidents recorded by customer service.
Criteria and weights
| Criterion | Weight | Where it comes from | How itâs calculated | Trust | If data is missing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer reviews | 40 % | Verified purchase reviews on VivelaVita: one per review, no reviews from other shops or repeated translations | Bayesian average: each model starts at the group's average and its reviews move it. So, 5 reviews of 5 stars don't beat 270 reviews of 4.8. Scale: 60/100 (3 stars) or less = 0, 100/100 = 10. | High with 20 or more reviews, medium with 5 to 19, low with fewer | That criterion isnât scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isnât bad. |
| Actual purchases | 25 % | Paid orders from the last 24 months, in net units after returns | Units per month since their first sale (so as not to punish new models), compared with the other models analysed: the most bought scores 10, the least 0. | High with 30 units or more, medium with 10 to 29, low with fewer | No missing data: zero sales is a data point |
| Price | 10 % | RRP including VAT compared to the median of the models analysed | A model at the median price scores 5; at half the price, 7.5; at double, 2.5. A kit with several plugs counts as one product, at its kit price. | High | That criterion isnât scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isnât bad. |
| Material | 10 % | Specification sheet: silicone, metal or glass, phthalate-free, non-porous, hypoallergenic; compared to PVC and ABS plastic | Starts at 5 and adds for silicone (+3), metal or glass (+2.5), phthalate-free (+1.5), non-porous (+1) and hypoallergenic (+0.5); PVC subtracts 2 and ABS plastic 0.5. It's what's declared on the sheet, not a lab analysis. | Medium: the sheet is filled out by people | That criterion isnât scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isnât bad. |
| Shape and feel | 8 % | Specification sheet: non-phallic shape, flexible and smooth texture | Starts at 5 and adds for plug shape and non-phallic (+2), for being flexible (+1.5) and for having a smooth texture (+1.5): what makes it easy to go in and out. | Medium: the sheet is filled out by people | That criterion isnât scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isnât bad. |
| Use and cleaning | 7 % | Technical sheet: waterproof, easy to clean and travel-friendly | Starts at 5 and adds for waterproof (+2), easy to clean (+2) and travel-friendly (+1). | Medium: the sheet is filled out by people | That criterion isnât scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isnât bad. |
The final score
Weighted average of the criteria for which there is data, from 0 to 10. In the event of a tie, it is decided in this order: purchase score, number of verified reviews and the lowest price.
The badges
- Best overall: The highest score with data from all criteria. Each model has at most one badge.
- Best value for money: The best score among those priced below average. Each model has at most one badge.
- Best for beginners: The highest rated among those marked for beginners. Each model has at most one badge.
- Best metal plug: The highest rated among metal plugs. Each model has at most one badge.
- Best silicone plug: The highest rated among silicone plugs. Each model has at most one badge.
What the AI does and doesnât do
The AI doesn't grade or decide the order. It drafts the 'why', the pros and cons, and the summary of opinions based on a closed data package, and every sentence must literally cite the opinion, the file, or the data it comes from; what can't be verified is discarded before publishing.
When the ranking changes
The data is recalculated every day, but the published order doesn't change automatically: when the new data moves it significantly, a person reviews and publishes a new version. This is version 31, reviewed on 16/10/2026. If we change the weight of the criteria, the no. 1 remains in 13 of 13 combinations.
Knocking on the door of the ranking
The next best-scoring models that don't make this list:
- Kit Anal 3 Plug 6,7/10
- All Black Plug 17 6,5/10
- Plug And Play 6,4/10
- Plug Hinchable 6,3/10
- All Black Plug For Top 6,2/10
- Anal Plug 16 5,5/10
