Plug Y Play S
8,9/10 4,9 (271)
The highest score with data from all criteria
15,50 âŹSee product
What are the best anal toys for men in 2026?
We've rated 19 anal toys for men âplugs, prostate massagers, beads, dilators, and anal vibratorsâ with verified purchase reviews, real purchases from the last 24 months, their price, and their spec sheets. These are the top 8 and who they suit best.
- 19 rated modelsof 99 in stock
- 495 reviewsverified purchase
- Genuine purchaseslast 24 months
- 14/09/2026last review
Text from RocĂo Moñino · PsicĂłloga / SexĂłloga en VivelaVita
Ranking calculated with shop data and reviewed by the VivelaVita product team
The best anal toys for men in 2026
One for every situation. If you're in a hurry, start here.
Mini Metal Butt Plug M
8,7/10 5,0 (7)
Metal anal plug with jewel, easy to clean and well priced.
12,95 âŹSee product
O Boy
8,4/10 5,0 (6)
O Boy stands out for its design and materials, ideal for stimulating the prostate and perineum.
32,00 âŹSee product
Mini Metal Butt Plug S
8,6/10 4,9 (11)
Small metallic anal plug, ideal for beginners, with jewel and competitive price.
10,50 âŹSee product
Reach Around
8,0/10 4,5 (13)
Reach Around stands out for its design and material, ideal for beginners in anal stimulation.
30,26 âŹSee product
Plug Silexd Conico
7,8/10 4,4 (18)
Premium silicone anal plug, flexible and hypoallergenic, ideal for experienced users.
16,95 âŹSee product
Comparison of the top 8 anal toys for men
In 'Zone', see which are for the prostate, and in 'Level', see who they're for.
| # | Product | Best for | Rating | Area | Material | Level | Vibrate | Price | Reviews | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Plug Y Play SSecret Play | Best overall | 8,9/10 | Anus | Metal | Beginner | No | 15,50 ⏠| 4,9 (271) | View |
| 2 |  Mini Metal Butt Plug MAlive | Best value for money | 8,7/10 | Anus | Metal | Intermediate | No | 12,95 ⏠| 5,0 (7) | View |
| 3 |  Mini Metal Butt Plug SAlive | Best for beginners | 8,6/10 | Anus | Metal | Beginner | No | 10,50 ⏠| 4,9 (11) | View |
| 4 |  O BoyRocks-off | Best for prostate | 8,4/10 | Anus, Prostate, Perineum | Silicone | Beginner | Yes | 32,00 ⏠| 5,0 (6) | View |
| 5 |  Reach AroundPipedream | Best vibrating | 8,0/10 | Anus, Prostate, Perineum | Silicone | Intermediate | Yes | 30,26 ⏠| 4,5 (13) | View |
| 6 |  Plug Silexd ConicoSilexd | Best for experienced users | 7,8/10 | Anus | Silicone | Advanced | No | 16,95 ⏠| 4,4 (18) | View |
| 7 |  DolinSeven Creations | â | 7,8/10 | Anus | Silicone | Intermediate | Yes | 18,50 ⏠| 5,0 (12) | Out of stock |
| 8 |  Petite Sensations PearlsRocks-off | â | 7,4/10 | Anus | Silicone | Beginner | Yes | 23,50 ⏠| 5,0 (7) | View |
15%
FOR EXTRA DISCOUNT
Use the code: BLOGVIVE and get an extra discount on Vivelavita for buying anal toys.
BLOGVIVE
How we chose the best
No guesswork. Each toy is rated with the same data and the same formula, and the formula is published. This covers anal toys from the menâs section of the shop and prostate massagers; general-use dildos, rings with an anal arm, lubes, hygiene products, and extreme level toys are excluded.
- Buyersâ Ratings40 %Reviews with verified order at VivelaVita: one per review, no other shops' reviews or repeated translations
- Real purchases25 %Paid orders from the last 24 months, net units of returns
- Price10 %RRP with VAT against the median of analysed models
- Shape and area9 %Technical sheet: marked for prostate, perineum support, no phallic shape, flexible and designed to ease anal sex
- Material10 %Technical sheet: silicone, metal or glass, phthalate-free, non-porous, hypoallergenic; against PVC and ABS plastic
- Ease of cleaning6 %Data sheet: easy to clean, waterproof
19 of 99 models in stock had at least 5 verified purchase reviews, which is the minimum to give them a rating. The others aren't worse: there's no data to say so.
If we change the weights, number 1 stays in 13 of 13 combinations.
See full methodologyAnalysis of each toy
Plug Y Play S
Secret Play · Smooth aluminium anal plug, thermal, cone-shaped and decorated
Best overallVivelaVita's rating8,9/10
The best bits
- Ease of cleaning: su ficha indica fĂĄcil limpieza, resistente al agua
- One of the best-selling in the group in recent months
- Highly rated by buyers: 4.9/5 in 271 verified reviews
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
Mini Metal Butt Plug M
Alive · Elegant metal anal plug with diamond, IPX8, lightweight
Best value for moneyVivelaVita's rating8,7/10
Why we've chosen it
Stands out for its ease of cleaning and good customer ratings. Also, its price is competitive and it has a non-phallic design that facilitates anal use.
The best bits
- Very good buyer ratings
- Competitive price
- Non-phallic design that facilitates anal sex
To bear in mind
- Metal material, may feel cold to the touch
- Small size, medium level of experience recommended
Ideal for
TravelEnhance orgasmsMake anal sex easier
I'd choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a similar plug with better overall score, I would choose Plug Y Play S. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
What the customers say
5,0 (7 verified)
Users positively rate the quality, elegant jewel design, and comfort of use with a partner.
+ Quality and design + Use with a partner
AI-generated summary based on verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsMini Metal Butt Plug S
Alive · Elegant, refreshing, and comfortable metal anal plug with jewel
Best for beginnersVivelaVita's rating8,6/10
Why we've chosen it
Stands out as the most affordable among the 8 models and well-rated by buyers. Its size and metal material make it comfortable and elegant to start with.
The best bits
- Very competitive price
- High buyer rating
- Ideal for beginners
- Metal material that provides a refreshing sensation
To bear in mind
- Non-phallic design
- Medium ease of cleaning
- Small size, may not be suitable for advanced users
Ideal for
Beginners with anal toysThose looking for a small and stylish plugUsers who value a low price
I'd choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a plug without vibration but with better cleanliness, I would choose Plug Y Play S View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
What the customers say
4,9 (11 verified)
Users positively rate the size for beginners, the quality of the metal, and the refreshing feel. Some highlight that it's pretty and comfortable to start with.
+ Size and comfort + Material and sensation
AI-generated summary based on verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsVivelaVita's rating8,4/10
Why we've chosen it
O Boy is a leader in shape, material and cleaning, with high ratings and focus on the prostate. Its price is higher, but offers advanced functions and superior quality.
The best bits
- Designed to stimulate prostate, perineum, and testicles
- Made of hypoallergenic silicone and phthalate-free
- Easy to clean and water-resistant
To bear in mind
- Priced higher than the market average
- Runs on batteries, non-rechargeable
Ideal for
Stimulate prostate and perineumUsers who value safe materialsThose looking for easy cleaning
I'd choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a non-vibrating and more affordable model, I would choose Plug Y Play S. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
What the customers say
5,0 (6 verified)
Users value its comfort, ease of insertion and strong vibration, although some wish for more intensity.
+ Comfort and ease of use + Vibration
AI-generated summary based on verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsVivelaVita's rating8,0/10
Why we've chosen it
This product is No. 1 in shape and area, material and ease of cleaning, making it very comfortable and safe. Its powerful vibration and ergonomic design make P-spot stimulation easier.
The best bits
- No. 1 in shape and area, ideal for prostate and perineum
- Made of hypoallergenic silicone and phthalate-free
- Easy to clean and waterproof
To bear in mind
- Higher price than the market median
- Some users don't feel enough pleasure or vibration
Ideal for
Beginners in anal stimulationPeople looking for an ergonomic designThose who value ease of cleaning
I'd choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a plug without vibration and more affordable, I'd choose Plug Y Play S. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
What the customers say
4,5 (13 verified)
Users appreciate the comfort, ergonomic design, and vibration power, though some mention not feeling enough pleasure or that the vibration is not sufficient. It's also noted for being quiet and easy to use.
+ Comfort and design + Vibration â Insufficient pleasure
AI-generated summary based on verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsPlug Silexd Conico
Silexd · Premium silicone anal plug, hypoallergenic and flexible
Best for experienced usersVivelaVita's rating7,8/10
Why we've chosen it
Stands out for its hypoallergenic and flexible silicone material, ideal for advanced users. Overall rating and sales are good, though its shape and size require experience.
The best bits
- Made of hypoallergenic silicone and phthalate-free
- Flexible and ergonomic to facilitate anal sex
- Ideal for users with experience in anal sex
To bear in mind
- Large size that may be uncomfortable for beginners
- Small base that may make removal difficult
- Shape and area scored low compared to other models
Ideal for
Users with experience in anal sexThose looking for a premium silicone plugPeople who value hypoallergenic materials
I'd choose another ifâŠ
If you're looking for a more versatile and beginner-friendly plug, I'd choose the Mini Metal Butt Plug S by Alive. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
What the customers say
4,4 (18 verified)
Users appreciate the quality of the material and flexibility, but warn that the size is large and the small base can be uncomfortable.
+ Material + Comfort and fit â Size â Base and removal
AI-generated summary based on verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsDolin
Seven Creations · Perfect vibrating anal plug for beginners
VivelaVita's rating7,8/10
18,50 âŹOut of stock right now
Why we've chosen it
It stands out as the #1 in customer ratings, with a non-phallic design and easy cleaning. Its price is competitive and it's perfect for starting out in anal sex.
The best bits
- Non-phallic design that facilitates anal sex
- Easy to clean
- Competitive price
To bear in mind
- Silicone and PVC material, less rated than others
- Average rating in ease of cleaning
- Average rating in shape and area
Ideal for
Beginners in anal sexCouples who want to startThose looking for a simple vibrating plug
I'd choose another ifâŠ
If you prefer a plug without vibration and with better ratings, I would choose Plug Y Play S View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
What the customers say
5,0 (12 verified)
Users appreciate its progressive size, smoothness and ease of use. They highlight its adjustable vibration and low noise, ideal for beginners.
+ Size and design + Vibration and noise
AI-generated summary based on verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsPetite Sensations Pearls
Rocks-off · Silicone vibrating anal plug with 7 speeds
VivelaVita's rating7,4/10
Why we've chosen it
It stands out as the #1 in ease of cleaning and for its good customer ratings. Its non-phallic shape facilitates anal sex and its material is silicone, comfortable and safe.
The best bits
- Very good buyer ratings
- Non-phallic shape that makes anal sex easier
- Comfortable and safe silicone material
To bear in mind
- Price a bit higher than the median
- 8th place in buying rate
- Runs on batteries, non-rechargeable
Ideal for
Introduction to anal sexCouples looking for vibrationTravel for its easy cleaning
I'd choose another ifâŠ
If youâre looking for a plug without vibration and more affordable, I would choose Plug Y Play S View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Score by criteria
What the customers say
5,0 (7 verified)
Users positively value the vibration power, the comfortable size and the ease of cleaning. They also highlight its pleasant feel and low noise.
+ vibration + comfort and size + ease of cleaning
AI-generated summary based on verified purchase reviews. It's not a quote.
Read all reviewsWhich to choose? It depends on what youâre after
Tap on what youâre after, and weâll tell you which one.
I'm looking for prostate stimulation
O Boy8,4/10 · 32,00 âŹSee recommendationIt's my first time with anything anal
Mini Metal Butt Plug S8,6/10 · 10,50 âŹSee recommendationI want it to vibrate
Reach Around8,0/10 · 30,26 âŹSee recommendationI've got experience
Plug Silexd Conico7,8/10 · 16,95 âŹSee recommendationI want to spend little
Mini Metal Butt Plug M8,7/10 · 12,95 âŹSee recommendationGive me the best one, no fuss
Plug Y Play S8,9/10 · 15,50 âŹSee recommendation
O Boy8,4/10 · 32,00 âŹSee recommendationIt's my first time with anything analMini Metal Butt Plug S8,6/10 · 10,50 âŹSee recommendationI want it to vibrateReach Around8,0/10 · 30,26 âŹSee recommendationI've got experiencePlug Silexd Conico7,8/10 · 16,95 âŹSee recommendationI want to spend littleMini Metal Butt Plug M8,7/10 · 12,95 âŹSee recommendationGive me the best one, no fussPlug Y Play S8,9/10 · 15,50 âŹSee recommendationWhat to check before buying
What anal toys are there for men
Almost all anal toys can be used by anyone, so what changes is the shape. Plugs are short, with a conical tip and a wide base, and they are meant to be left in place. Prostate stimulators have a tip curved forward and often a branch that rests outside, on the perineum. Balls and anal beads are inserted and removed gradually. And there are dilators and plugs of various sizes for those who have experience.
This comparison includes anal toys from the men's section of the store and prostate stimulators. General use dildos, cock rings with anal arms, lubricants, and hygiene are excluded.
The shape: curved tip, perineum, and base
If you're looking for a prostate stimulator, pay attention to three aspects of the shape, which distinguish it from a straight plug:
- Curved or slightly bulging tip, designed to be oriented forward.
- A branch or external support for the perineum, if that area interests you.
- Wide base, ring, or handle that acts as a stopper: it cannot be missing from any anal toy.
In the "Zone" column of the table, you can see which toys are marked for the prostate and which also support the perineum.
Size and experience level
If it's your first time, start with a thin, short model: what stands out is the diameter of the widest part, not the length. Inflatable plugs, dilators with rings, and larger sizes are for those who have practice. The "Level" column in the table reflects what each product's description says, and if in doubt, a kit with various sizes allows you to try them out.
Material and lubricant
Silicone is soft and flexible and is the most common in prostate stimulators. Metal and glass are rigid and smooth, weigh more, and can be warmed or cooled with water. PVC and hard plastic are cheaper and score lower in the material criterion.
With an anal toy, lubricant is not optional. Water-based ones work with any material; silicone-based ones last longer but should not be used with silicone toys.
With or without vibration
It's a matter of taste, and it doesn't score by itself. A plug without a motor is simpler and cleans up quickly. One with vibration adds another sensation and usually comes with various modes; check if it runs on batteries or is rechargeable and if it includes a remote, especially if you plan to use it with a partner. The "Vibra" column shows it at a glance.
Cleaning and how to use this comparison
Wash it after each use with warm water and mild soap or a toy cleaner; those that are water-resistant and without gaps are the most convenient. The rating of each toy comes from verified purchase opinions, what people actually buy, the price, and what the product description states about the zone, material, and cleaning. Start with the highlights if you're in a hurry and compare the ones you're interested in in the table.
Frequently Asked Questions
Whatâs the best anal toy for men?
Based on this review, the Plug Y Play S, with 8,9/10. However, it depends on what youâre after: if itâs for the prostate, go for the O Boy; if itâs your first time, try the Mini Metal Butt Plug S; and if youâre looking at price, the Mini Metal Butt Plug M.
Are there anal toys specifically for men?
Almost all can be used by anyone. Whatâs specific to men is the shape of prostate massagers: a forward-curved tip and often a perineum tab. In the âZoneâ column of the table, you can see which ones are listed for prostate.
Plug or prostate massager?
A plug is straight, with a broad base, and is left in place. A prostate massager has a curved tip and often rests externally. The top-rated prostate one is the O Boy, with 8,4/10; if you prefer a plug, check the âZoneâ column and stick with those marked âAnoâ only.
With or without vibration?
Itâs a matter of taste: vibration doesnât boost the score by itself. The highest-rated vibrator is the Reach Around, with 8,0/10. The âVibraâ column of the table shows which have a motor.
What if Iâve got experience?
Look in the âLevelâ column for those marked as advanced: inflatable plugs, dilators with rings, and larger sizes. The highest-rated of them is the Plug Silexd Conico.
Which has the best value for money?
The Mini Metal Butt Plug M: itâs the highest-rated among those costing less than average, priced at 12,95 âŹ.
How many anal toys have you reviewed?
We started with 99 anal toys for men that are in stock. We rated the 19 with enough verified purchase reviews, and here are the top 8.
About this comparison
- Last review
- 14/09/2026 · version 1 of the ranking
- Text
- RocĂo Moñino, psicĂłloga / sexĂłloga en vivelavita
- Ranking
- Calculated with algorithm mejores-v1 and reviewed by the VivelaVita product team
- Data analysed
- 99 models in stock, 19 rated, 495 verified purchase reviews, and orders paid from 24 months
The order and scores are from the version published on 14/09/2026. The price, stock, and number of reviews update automatically and may have changed: check each product's page before buying.
See all anal products for menComplete methodology
Which products are included
All from the category and subcategories that are currently active, in stock, and priced (99 models). Accessories and spare parts, discontinued items, and those with less than 5 verified purchase reviews are excluded: 80 models aren't worse, they just don't have enough data.
What data is used
Only reviews with an actual order behind them, counted once even if translated into multiple languages; never reviews copied from other stores. Sales from paid orders over the last 24 months, excluding returns. The technical sheet of each model. The price with VAT. And the incidents recorded by customer service.
Criteria and weights
| Criteria | Weight | Where it comes from | How it's calculated | Trust | If data is missing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buyersâ Ratings | 40 % | Reviews with verified order at VivelaVita: one per review, no other shops' reviews or repeated translations | Bayesian average: each model starts with the group's average and its reviews move it. So 5 reviews of 5 stars don't beat 270 reviews of 4.8. Scale: 60/100 (3 stars) or less = 0, 100/100 = 10. | High with 20 or more reviews, medium with 5 to 19, low with less | That criterion isn't scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isn't bad. |
| Real purchases | 25 % | Paid orders from the last 24 months, net units of returns | Units per month since its first sale (to not penalise new models), compared with the rest of analysed models: the one bought most gets 10, the least 0. | High with 30 units or more, medium with 10 to 29, low with less | No missing data: zero sales is still data |
| Price | 10 % | RRP with VAT against the median of analysed models | A model at the median price gets 5; at half the price, 7.5; at double, 2.5. A kit counts as one product, at its kit price. | High | That criterion isn't scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isn't bad. |
| Shape and area | 9 % | Technical sheet: marked for prostate, perineum support, no phallic shape, flexible and designed to ease anal sex | Starts at 5 and adds if marked for prostate (+2), if it also supports the perineum (+1), for having no phallic shape âcommon in plugs and stimulators with base or stopperâ (+1.5), for being flexible (+0.5) and for being designed to ease anal sex (+0.5). | Medium: people fill out the sheet | That criterion isn't scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isn't bad. |
| Material | 10 % | Technical sheet: silicone, metal or glass, phthalate-free, non-porous, hypoallergenic; against PVC and ABS plastic | Starts at 5 and adds for silicone (+3), metal or glass (+2.5), phthalate-free (+1.5), non-porous (+1) and hypoallergenic (+0.5); PVC subtracts 2 and ABS plastic 0.5. It's what the sheet declares, not a lab analysis. | Medium: people fill out the sheet | That criterion isn't scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isn't bad. |
| Ease of cleaning | 6 % | Data sheet: easy to clean, waterproof | Starts at 5 and adds for easy cleaning (+3) and waterproof (+2). For anal use, wash it well after each use is not optional. | Medium | That criterion isn't scored and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown isn't bad. |
The final score
Weighted average of the criteria with data, from 0 to 10. In the event of a tie, itâs decided in this order: purchase score, number of verified reviews, and lowest price.
The badges
- Best overall: The highest score with data from all criteria. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best value for money: The highest score among those costing less than the average. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best for prostate: The highest rated for those marked for prostate in the data sheet. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best for beginners: The highest rated for those marked for beginners in the data sheet. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best vibrating: The highest rated among those that vibrate. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best for experienced users: The highest rated for those marked as advanced level in the data sheet. Each model carries at most one badge.
What the AI does and doesn't do
The AI doesn't write notes or decide the order. It drafts the 'why', the pros and cons, and the summary of opinions from a closed data package, and every sentence has to quote exactly the opinion, the sheet or the data it comes from; anything that can't be verified is dismissed before publishing.
When the ranking changes
The data is recalculated every day, but the published order doesn't change automatically: when the new data moves it significantly, a person reviews and publishes a new version. This is version 1, reviewed on 14/09/2026. If we change the weighting of the criteria, the No. 1 remains in 13 out of 13 combinations.
On the brink of the ranking
The next best-scoring models that aren't in this list:
- Inflatable Butt Plug L 7,4/10
- Plug & Play 7,3/10
- P-rock 7,2/10
- Delux Vibro Bolas 7,0/10
- Sono NÂș 50 6,7/10
- Nevor 6,2/10
- Plug Hinchable 6,2/10
- Plug And Play 6,1/10
