Plug Y Play S
9,0/10 4,9 (271)
The highest score with data from all criteria
15,50 €View product
What are the best beginner anal toys of 2026?
We have rated 12 anal toys marked for beginners —plugs, balls, kits, and small vibrators— with verified purchase reviews, actual purchases from the last 24 months, their price, and their technical specifications. Here are the top 7 and who they're for.
- 12 scored modelsof 155 in stock
- 378 reviewsfrom verified purchase
- Real buyslast 24 months
- 14/09/2026last review
Text from Anel Martinez · Sexóloga
Ranking calculated with shop data and reviewed by the VivelaVita product team
The best beginner anal toys of 2026
One for each case. If you're in a rush, start here.
Mini Metal Butt Plug S
8,8/10 4,9 (11)
Small metal plug, ideal for beginners, with good value for money and elegant design.
10,50 €View product
O Boy
8,6/10 5,0 (6)
O Boy stands out for its ideal size for beginners, safe material and easy cleaning.
32,00 €View product
Petite Sensations Pearls
8,4/10 5,0 (7)
Small vibrating anal plug, easy to clean with good vibration for beginners.
23,50 €View product
Dorthos
6,5/10 5,0 (14)
Dorthos is a soft and affordable anal plug, ideal for beginners looking for comfort and ease of use.
7,95 €View product
Comparison of the top 7 beginner anal toys
In 'Size' you see which ones are small and in 'Material', what each one is made of.
| # | Product | Best for | Score | Size | Material | Feel | Vibrates | Price | Reviews | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Plug Y Play SSecret Play | Best overall | 9,0/10 | Small | Metal | Rigid | No | 15,50 € | 4,9 (271) | View |
| 2 |  Mini Metal Butt Plug SAlive | Best value for money | 8,8/10 | Small | Metal | Rigid | No | 10,50 € | 4,9 (11) | View |
| 3 |  O BoyRocks-off | Best small | 8,6/10 | Small | Silicone | — | Yes | 32,00 € | 5,0 (6) | View |
| 4 |  Petite Sensations PearlsRocks-off | Best vibrating | 8,4/10 | Small | Silicone | — | Yes | 23,50 € | 5,0 (7) | View |
| 5 |  Ultimate DoucheCalexotics | — | 7,9/10 | — | — | — | — | 7,78 € | 4,9 (19) | View |
| 6 |  Ass ExpanderPipedream | — | 7,0/10 | Medium | Silicone | — | — | 25,50 € | 4,6 (5) | View |
| 7 |  DorthosPipedream | Best soft silicone | 6,5/10 | — | Silicone | Flexible | — | 7,95 € | 5,0 (14) | View |
15%
FOR EXTRA DISCOUNT
Use the code: BLOGVIVE and get an extra discount on Vivelavita to buy anal toys.
BLOGVIVE
How we chose the best
No guessing involved. Each toy is scored with the same data and formula, and the formula is published. Only beginner-level anal toys are included: mid or advanced level toys, general-use dildos, lubricants and hygiene are excluded.
- Buyer ratings40 %Reviews with verified purchase on VivelaVita: one per review, no reviews from other shops or repeated translations
- Real purchases25 %Paid orders from the last 24 months, in units net of returns
- Price10 %RRP with VAT against the median of the models analysed
- Size and shape to start with10 %Technical data sheet: small size, no phallic shape, flexible and designed to ease anal sex; against large size
- Material10 %Technical data sheet: silicone, metal or glass, phthalate-free, non-porous, hypoallergenic; against PVC and ABS plastic
- Ease of cleaning5 %Tech specs: easy to clean, waterproof
12 out of 155 models in stock had at least 5 verified purchase reviews, which is the minimum needed to rate them. The rest are not worse: there's no data to say so.
If we change the weights, the nº 1 remains in 13 of 13 combinations.
See complete methodologyAnalysis of each toy
VivelaVita Review9,0/10
The best bits
- One of the most purchased in the group in recent months
- Ease of cleaning: su ficha indica fácil limpieza, resistente al agua
- Highly rated by those who bought it: 4.9/5 in 271 verified reviews
View score by criteria and opinions
Scores by criteria
Mini Metal Butt Plug S
Alive · Elegant, refreshing, and comfortable metal anal plug with jewel
Best value for moneyVivelaVita Review8,8/10
Why we chose it
Stands out as the no. 1 in size and shape for starting out, with good ratings and a competitive price. Its metallic, non-phallic design makes it comfortable and elegant.
The best bits
- Competitive price for its category
- Sleek and comfortable metallic design
Worth keeping in mind
- Slightly harder to clean
- Metal material may feel cold
Perfect for
Beginners in anal toysThose looking for a small and non-phallic plugUsers who appreciate an elegant and discreet design
Choose another if…
If you prefer a plug with better ease of cleaning and without the cold sensation, I'd choose Plug Y Play S. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Scores by criteria
What customers say
4,9 (11 verified)
Users rate the beginner size and quality of the metal very positively, although some mention the cold sensation of the material.
+ Beginner size + Quality and design – Cold feeling
Summary made with AI based on verified purchase opinions. Not a quote.
Read all the opinionsVivelaVita Review8,6/10
Why we chose it
O Boy is the No. 1 in size and shape for starting, material and ease of cleaning, making it very comfortable and safe for beginners. Its overall score and buyer rating are also high.
The best bits
- Small and non-phallic, ideal for beginners
- Hypoallergenic silicone material and phthalate-free
- Easy to clean and water-resistant
Worth keeping in mind
- Higher price than the market median
- Powerful vibration but a bit noisy
- Battery operated, not rechargeable
Perfect for
Beginners in anal toysThose looking for safe material and easy cleaningUsers who prefer small size and non-phallic shape
Choose another if…
If you prefer a non-vibrating and more affordable plug, I'd choose Plug Y Play S. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Scores by criteria
What customers say
5,0 (6 verified)
Users appreciate its ideal size, easy insertion and pleasant vibration, though some mention it could be more powerful and is a bit noisy.
+ Comfort and size
Summary made with AI based on verified purchase opinions. Not a quote.
Read all the opinionsVivelaVita Review8,4/10
Why we chose it
Known for being the no. 1 in size and shape for starters and in ease of cleaning, with good ratings and vibration. Its price is average within the group.
The best bits
- Small and non-phallic, ideal for beginners
- Easy to clean and water-resistant
- Powerful vibration with 7 speeds
Worth keeping in mind
- Average price within the comparison
- Battery operated, not rechargeable
Perfect for
Beginners in anal toysThose looking for easy cleaningUsers who prefer adjustable vibration
Choose another if…
If you're after a non-vibrating and cheaper plug, I'd go for the Mini Metal Butt Plug S. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Scores by criteria
What customers say
5,0 (7 verified)
Users appreciate the powerful vibration, comfortable size, and ease of cleaning. The good material and suitability for couple use are also noted.
+ Vibration + Size and comfort + Ease of cleaning
Summary made with AI based on verified purchase opinions. Not a quote.
Read all the opinionsUltimate Douche
Calexotics · Anal cleaner for men and women; easy to use and clean
VivelaVita Review7,9/10
Why we chose it
This product is the cheapest and has a high rating, although its size is the least suitable for beginners. Its ease of cleaning is acceptable but not outstanding.
The best bits
- Very competitive price
- High buyer rating
- Compatible with water-based lubricants
Worth keeping in mind
- Size and shape less suitable for beginners
- Acceptable but not outstanding ease of cleaning
Perfect for
Those looking for an economical anal cleanerUsers who value ease of usePeople who prefer a product compatible with water-based lubricants
Choose another if…
If you prefer a product with a better size to start, I would choose the Plug Y Play S View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Scores by criteria
What customers say
4,9 (19 verified)
Users appreciate the product's comfort, ease of use and cleaning, although some find the size and firmness less comfortable.
+ Comfort and ease of use + Cleaning – Size and comfort
Summary made with AI based on verified purchase opinions. Not a quote.
Read all the opinionsAss Expander
Pipedream · Inflatable plug to adjust the size to your liking
VivelaVita Review7,0/10
Why we chose it
Stands out as the No. 1 in ease of cleaning and for its phthalate-free silicone material. It’s anal safe and allows you to adjust the size, ideal for beginners.
The best bits
- Phthalate-free silicone material
- Safe for anal and without a phallic shape
Worth keeping in mind
- Priced higher than the median
- Medium size, may be small for some
- Reviews mention it could be a bit bigger
Perfect for
Beginners in anal sexThose looking for an adjustable plugUsers who value easy cleaning
Choose another if…
If you prefer a more economical plug with a jewel, I would choose Plug Y Play S. View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Scores by criteria
What customers say
4,6 (5 verified)
Users appreciate the comfort and quality of the product, though some wish for a larger size. Highlights include the ease of sharing moments with a partner and comfortable expansion.
+ Comfort + Quality – Size
Summary made with AI based on verified purchase opinions. Not a quote.
Read all the opinionsVivelaVita Review6,5/10
Why we chose it
Stands out as the highest rated by buyers and the cheapest in the ranking. Its flexibility and easy cleaning make it accessible for those starting out.
The best bits
- Flexible and easy to clean
- Safe material and phthalate-free
Worth keeping in mind
- Size and shape less valued for beginners
- Not outstanding in ease of cleaning compared with others
Perfect for
Beginners in anal playThose looking for a soft plugTight budget
Choose another if…
If you prefer a plug with better overall rating and more features, I would choose Plug Y Play S View analysis
View score by criteria and opinions
Scores by criteria
What customers say
5,0 (14 verified)
Users rate its comfort, softness and ease of use for beginners. They highlight that it is soft, easy to clean, and suitable for beginners.
+ Comfort and softness + Ease of cleaning
Summary made with AI based on verified purchase opinions. Not a quote.
Read all the opinionsWhich one to choose? Depends on what you're after
Tap what you're looking for and we'll tell you which one.
I want something small to start with
O Boy8,6/10 · 32,00 €See recommendationI prefer it soft and flexible
Dorthos6,5/10 · 7,95 €See recommendationI want it to vibrate
Petite Sensations Pearls8,4/10 · 23,50 €See recommendationI want to spend less
Mini Metal Butt Plug S8,8/10 · 10,50 €See recommendationJust give me the best one
Plug Y Play S9,0/10 · 15,50 €See recommendation
O Boy8,6/10 · 32,00 €See recommendationI prefer it soft and flexibleDorthos6,5/10 · 7,95 €See recommendationI want it to vibratePetite Sensations Pearls8,4/10 · 23,50 €See recommendationI want to spend lessMini Metal Butt Plug S8,8/10 · 10,50 €See recommendationJust give me the best onePlug Y Play S9,0/10 · 15,50 €See recommendationWhat to look for before buying
What anal toys are available for beginners
Almost everything bought for the first time falls into four families. Plugs are short, with a tapered tip, a narrower neck, and a wide base: they are put in and left in place. Anal beads or rosaries are a row of spheres that usually grow in size and are inserted and removed gradually. Kits come with two or three plugs of different sizes to progress as desired. There are also small plugs and stimulators with vibration.
This comparison only includes those marked in the data sheet for beginner level. Intermediate or advanced levels, general-use dildos, lubricants, and hygiene are excluded.
Size and shape: the first thing to check
To start, the smaller and thinner, the better. Look at the diameter of the widest part more than the total length, because that is what is noticeable. In the "Size" column of the table, you can see which ones the data sheet marks as small.
- Tapered or rounded tip, for smooth insertion.
- Wide base or ring that acts as a stopper: this is essential in any anal toy.
- Smooth surface, without seams or marked reliefs.
- If uncertain between two sizes, a kit lets you try several without buying three times.
Silicone, metal, or glass
Silicone is soft and flexible, adapts to the body, and is the most common option for the first time. Metal and glass are rigid and smooth, weigh more, and can be warmed or cooled with water; many people enjoy this firmness. PVC and hard plastic are cheaper and score lower in material criteria.
The lubricant counts too: water-based ones work with any material, and silicone-based ones should not be used with silicone toys. In the "Material" column, you see what each one is made of.
With or without vibration
It's a matter of taste. A plug without a motor is simpler, cheaper, and easier to clean. One with vibration adds another sensation and usually brings several modes, but is heavier and requires batteries or charging. If unsure, start without vibration and there's always time later. The "Vibra" column in the table gives you a quick look.
Cleaning and care
For anal use, washing the toy after each use is not optional. Those with smooth surfaces, without gaps, and water-resistant are the most convenient: warm water, mild soap, or a toy cleaner, and dry. Store it in its bag and separate from other toys, especially if it’s silicone.
How to use this comparison
The grade of each toy comes from verified purchase opinions, actual purchases, price, and what its data sheet declares about size, shape, material, and cleaning. If you are in a hurry, start with the highlights; if you want to compare, check the size and material in the table and read the analysis of the ones you are interested in.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best beginner anal toy?
Based on this review, the Plug Y Play S, scoring 9,0/10. But it depends on what you're after: if you want the smallest, go for O Boy; if you prefer it soft, then Dorthos; and if you're price-conscious, Mini Metal Butt Plug S.
What size should I pick for my first time?
The smallest and thinnest you can find: it's the diameter of the widest part that matters, not the length. The highest-rated one marked as small size is the O Boy. Check the 'Size' column in the table for the rest.
Silicone or metal to start?
Silicone is soft and flexible; metal is rigid, smooth, heavier, and you can warm it with water. Both clean well. The top-rated flexible silicone is Dorthos, and in the 'Material' column, you can see what each is made of.
With or without vibration?
It's a matter of taste: vibrating doesn't add to the score on its own. Without a motor, it's simpler and cheaper; with vibration, it adds another sensation. The highest rated one that vibrates is Petite Sensations Pearls, with 8,4/10.
Why only beginner-marked toys?
Because the comparison is for beginners. It includes anal toys labelled 'Beginner Level' and excludes those marked as intermediate or advanced. General use dildos, lubricants and hygiene items are not included.
Which has the best value for money?
The Mini Metal Butt Plug S: it's the top scorer among those priced below average, costing 10,50 €.
How many toys have you analysed?
We started with 155 beginner anal toys in stock. We scored the 12 with enough verified purchase reviews, and here are the top 7.
About this comparison
- Last review
- 14/09/2026 · version 1 of the ranking
- Text
- Anel Martinez, sexóloga
- Ranking
- Calculated with the mejores-v1 algorithm and reviewed by the VivelaVita product team
- Data analysed
- 155 models in stock, 12 rated, 378 verified purchase reviews and the orders paid from 24 months
The order and the scores are from the version published on 14/09/2026. The price, stock, and number of reviews update automatically and may have changed: check each product's page before buying.
See all beginner anal toysComplete methodology
What products are included
All from the category and its subcategories that are currently active, in stock and priced (155 models). Excluding accessories and spare parts, discontinued ones and those with fewer than 5 verified purchase reviews for rating: 143 models which aren't worse, just lacking enough data.
What data is used
Only reviews with a real order behind them, counted once even if translated into several languages; never reviews copied from other stores. Sales from paid orders over the last 24 months, excluding returns. The technical sheet of each model. The price with VAT included. And issues recorded by customer service.
Criteria and weights
| Criteria | Weight | Where it comes from | How it's calculated | Trust | If the data is missing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer ratings | 40 % | Reviews with verified purchase on VivelaVita: one per review, no reviews from other shops or repeated translations | Bayesian average: each model starts with the group average and its reviews move it. So 5 reviews of 5 stars don’t beat 270 reviews of 4.8. Scale: 60/100 (3 stars) or less = 0, 100/100 = 10. | High with 20 or more reviews, medium with 5 to 19, low with fewer | That criterion isn't rated and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown doesn't mean bad. |
| Real purchases | 25 % | Paid orders from the last 24 months, in units net of returns | Units per month since their first sale (to not punish new models), compared with other models analysed: the top seller scores 10, the least 0. | High with 30 units or more, medium with 10 to 29, low with fewer | No missing data: zero sales is data |
| Price | 10 % | RRP with VAT against the median of the models analysed | A model at the median price scores 5; at half the price, 7.5; at double, 2.5. A kit counts as one product, with its kit price. | High | That criterion isn't rated and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown doesn't mean bad. |
| Size and shape to start with | 10 % | Technical data sheet: small size, no phallic shape, flexible and designed to ease anal sex; against large size | Starts at 5 and adds for small size (+2), for not having a phallic shape (+1.5), for being flexible (+1) and for being designed to ease anal sex (+0.5); if marked as large, subtract 1.5. | Medium: the data sheet is filled out by people | That criterion isn't rated and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown doesn't mean bad. |
| Material | 10 % | Technical data sheet: silicone, metal or glass, phthalate-free, non-porous, hypoallergenic; against PVC and ABS plastic | Starts at 5 and adds for silicone (+3), metal or glass (+2.5), phthalate-free (+1.5), non-porous (+1) and hypoallergenic (+0.5); PVC subtracts 2 and ABS plastic 0.5. It is what the data sheet states, not a lab analysis. | Medium: the data sheet is filled out by people | That criterion isn't rated and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown doesn't mean bad. |
| Ease of cleaning | 5 % | Tech specs: easy to clean, waterproof | Starts at 5 and adds up for easy to clean (+3) and waterproof (+2). For anal use, a good wash after every use is not optional. | Average | That criterion isn't rated and its weight is distributed among the others. Unknown doesn't mean bad. |
The final score
Weighted average of criteria with data, from 0 to 10. In case of a draw, it decides in this order: purchase score, number of verified reviews, and lowest price.
The badges
- Best overall: The highest score with data from all criteria. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best value for money: The best score among those costing less than average. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best small: The highest rated among small-sized as marked. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best vibrating: Top rated among the vibrating ones. Each model carries at most one badge.
- Best soft silicone: The highest rated among flexible silicone and non-motorized. Each model carries at most one badge.
What the AI does and does not do
The AI doesn't put grades or decide the order. It drafts the 'why', the pros and cons, and the summary of opinions based on a closed data package, and each sentence has to literally cite the opinion, file or data it comes from; what can't be verified is discarded before publishing.
When the ranking changes
The data is recalculated every day, but the published order doesn't change on its own: when new data shifts it significantly, a person reviews and publishes a new version. This is version 1, reviewed on 14/09/2026. If we change the criteria weights, the No. 1 remains in 13 out of 13 combinations.
On the brink of the ranking
The next best scoring models that don't make it into this list:
- Plug Metal Grande 6,9/10
- Kit Anal 3 Plug 6,5/10
- Plug Play Largo 6,4/10
- Plug And Play 6,2/10
- Nevor 6,2/10
